← In The Field
In The Field

In The Field 011: Introducing Freebie Paradox | The High Cost Of Free

4 min read
Screenshot of the hero section of a thrown-in website, showing lack of attention to detail.

Screenshot of the hero section of a thrown-in website, showing lack of attention to detail.

I walked into a nail salon in Blacksburg recently. Good service, clean space, the kind of place that earns repeat customers on quality alone. I asked, the way I usually do, whether they had a website.

They said yes. It came bundled with their credit card processor.

I pulled it up while I was sitting in the chair.

What I Found

The hero section, the first thing any visitor sees, reads "Covert your days into occasions." Not convert. Covert. The single most prominent line of text on the entire site is misspelled, and it has been live since the site went up.

The about section reads like it was written for no salon in particular and dropped into this one. Soothing ambiance. Organic spa products. Thoughtful and prompt service. None of it is wrong, but none of it is specific either. It could describe this salon or any of a thousand others. Nothing on the page tells you what makes this one different, because nothing on the page was written with this one in mind.

Then I checked the source code, which is where it actually got bad.

The page has a meta robots tag set to noindex, nofollow. In plain terms, that is an explicit instruction telling every search engine not to index the page and not to follow any links on it.

This is not a slow site.

This is not a poorly optimized site.

This is a site that has told Google directly not to show it to anyone, ever.

What Bundled Actually Means

The owner did not build this website and did not choose this website. It came as a sweetener attached to a credit card processing agreement, the kind of package deal where a sales rep says something like "and we'll throw in a free website" to close the processing contract. The website was never the product being sold. It was the incentive to get a signature on something else.

That explains everything I found. The misspelling that nobody caught because nobody who built it is paying attention, and nobody who runs the salon knows enough to catch it themselves. The generic copy that was clearly written once and reused across an unknown number of other small businesses processing payments through the same company. And the noindex tag, almost certainly a leftover from a staging or template environment that was supposed to be removed before launch and never was, because nobody on the building end had a reason to check, and nobody on the salon end knew the tag existed at all.

A website built this way is not part of a digital foundation. It is a failure, merely a box that got checked.

The Freebie Paradox

This salon could have outstanding reviews. They could be the best in Blacksburg. None of it matters to Google because Google has been told explicitly not to look. A customer searching for a nail salon in Blacksburg will never find this page in the results, not because the competition is fierce, but because the site asked not to be found and nobody noticed it asked.

The owner has no idea any of this is happening. They are running a salon, not auditing meta tags. They were told a website was included and they believed, reasonably, that included meant functional.

That is the Freebie Paradox. The website exists. The box is checked. The problem is invisible to the person who has it and unexamined by everyone who put it there.

The Afterthought Problem

There is also a reason a credit card processor should not be offering websites. Processing payments and building a functional web presence are not related disciplines. One has nothing to do with the other. It is the equivalent of going to get a bagel and being offered an oil change. The fact that both involve a transaction does not mean the same vendor should be doing both.

"Bundled website" should be a warning label, not a selling point. The moment a website gets treated as an add-on to something else, a payment processor, a phone system, a business card printer, it stops being infrastructure and becomes a checkbox. Nobody builds a checkbox carefully.

Nobody maintains a checkbox.

Nobody is accountable for whether a checkbox actually works.

A website is not an also-ran. It is one of the central pillars of a business's Digital Foundation, alongside the Google Business Profile, alongside consistent NAP data, alongside everything that determines whether a customer can find a business and trust what they find when they get there. Treating it as a bonus thrown in to close a different sale guarantees it will be built by whoever was cheapest, checked by no one, and maintained by nobody once the ink on the processing agreement is dry.

If a sales rep ever tells you a website comes bundled with something else, that should be the moment you ask more questions, not fewer. A real website is not free. It is not an incentive. It is not a line item added to make a different product look more generous.

The businesses that treat their website this way are telling you, whether they realize it or not, exactly how much thought went into building it.

Anyone who hears the words bundled website should be stop and wonder if they want a cornerstone of their foundation to be slapped together instead of constructed properly.

Terms Used in This Post
Google Business Profile
Google Business Profile (GBP) is a free Google tool that lets a business control how it appears in Google Search and Google Maps, including its name, address, phone number, hours, photos, and customer reviews.
Digital Foundation
A Digital Foundation is the underlying technical infrastructure that determines a business's visibility, security, and deliverability. It is the "chassis" of your online presence, if the foundation is cracked with poor code, badly managed GBP, missing security protocols, or broken DNS, no amount of marketing or pretty pictures will make the business successful.
Freebie Paradox
The Freebie Paradox occurs when a website or digital asset offered at no cost as part of a bundled package creates more damage to a business than having no web presence at all. The business owner believes they have a functioning digital foundation because something was included. The inclusion is the problem.
Nofollow
Nofollow is an instruction placed in a website's code that tells search engines not to follow the links on a page to discover other content. A page set to nofollow stops search engines from using its links as pathways to find and index other pages. It does not prevent the page itself from appearing in search results but it severs the connections that help search engines understand how the site is structured.
Noindex
Noindex is an instruction placed in a website's code that tells search engines not to include a specific page in their search results. A page set to noindex can still exist and be visited directly, but it will not appear when someone searches for it. To search engines, it does not exist.
NAP
NAP stands for Name, Address, Phone. It refers to the three core pieces of business identity that must appear consistently everywhere the business exists online. When they match, search engines build confidence. When they conflict, that confidence erodes and local search visibility suffers.

Is This Your Site?

If your digital presence has problems like these, we can fix them. Start with a free assessment — no commitment, no pitch, straight conversation about what's wrong and what it would take to fix it.

Get a Free Assessment →